Re: Electric fan=how much hp?
few years back i considered electrics for my red truck and did alot of research,red alot on the s-10 forum and other sights like superchargerson,the pa fourm(lot of s/c freaks over there),ect...also found an old Carcraft mag.in my PILES of mags.that did an engine dyno test with a motor making 500hp. they swapped all these diff.clutches to the fans...rpm activated,heat activated,non-clutch...the most gain,or rather least amount of hp loss came down to the extreme(or severe) duty thermal clutch that lost only 5-7 hp. where as some of the rpm activated and non-clutch(like the flex-a-lite solid blade) ones sucked up like 22+hp!
in the end i passed on electric and put an 'extreme duty' thermal clutch on a stock fan. i just put one in the ty too, cause the ac was failing at low rpms(idling in traffic)... all the oil leaked out of the viscous..no lock up.
yes,the clutch fan is alittle noisey,but very effecient.
soo i guess by those results,you could pick up 5-7 hp by swapping to an electric set up,perhaps a few more with an elec.waterpump set up....for me,dollars to hp, i dident feel it was worth it. at the time the s-10 elec. flex-a-lite set up was near 400 bucks. alot moe options nowadays tho.
altho based on research and solid data,still just my opinion.