I want to hear from all the 9/11 users and ex-users.

I want to hear from all the 9/11 users and ex-users.


  • Total voters
    1

Sy769

Donating Member
Well the PTE 60 bug has bitten since a buddy brought his latest UPS delivery by the house.

So now we both need torque converters.

Rumor has it that Mike Lee can still get the 9/11's even though I also heard they were being discontinued.

Don't even mention the new 9/11 as I am not gonna give a grand for a TC even if it sucks my d**k when I open the box. :p

I want to hear the good and bad experiences with the 9/11. The shudder condition, overly loose feeling-that stuff. Also I want to hear the success stories with it and with other brands of converters. I am figuring at a 2800-3000k stall for the PTE60.

I don't care if you don't like Hartman,TCS,me,or your momma. I want to hear how it worked and what the end result was.

Reason I ask is I over the last few years I have read how the 9/11 was THE converter for syty's but here lately all I have read are negative comments.
Tc replacement is a pain in the ass enough that I only want to do it once. I don't want to be a pioneer or run off the same cliff with the rest of the herd either.
Thanks fellas
 

smeagol

Active member
I had one in my built Syclone. Performance was good, drivability was poor. It stalled up like it should and lasted for all of my racing. It had the lockup shudder *at low speeds*.

Had one in my current stock-ish Syclone (bolt ons only, stock motor) and I hated it. It was just too loose. Shift points were too high; on a datalog, they were nearly imperceptible.

I know of several others that had *way* too loose of converters as well. Whether it's line pressure, or whatever, at fault, it seems to be too much hit or miss to see if you get a good one.

I don't like them on a stock motor truck.

I would *consider* one on a built truck, but also see what other options are out there.
 

myclone

Donating Member
I like mine for the most part but Ive got wierd likes/dislikes... Anyway, mine has stood up to me abusing it fine and I guess I got lucky and never had any of the shuddering problems. Mine is a 3k stall and is a tad loose for my taste but Ive had plans all along to upgrade to a bigger turbo than I already have so it will be needed anyway.

With an open dump you will atract the 5.0 unless you get pretty good at spotting them first and then throwing the trans in nuetral to coast by them :D .

Kills your gas milage. Not a prob for me as I didnt buy the truck for its milage.

It would prolly suck on a stock turbo'd engine as spool up/over boost would be insane IMO. I dunno as I never ran my 9/11 with the stock turbo.

Stop and go traffic driving would be a PIA for most ppl IMO. I dont mind myself as my truck is a fair weather toy not a daily driver.

Im with you on not paying a grand for a TC. Is it worth it? Maybe but not to me. I'll try some other companies TCs first and when I get to a point they wont last my minimal track time then I'll step up to the $1k TC.

Ive heard the same complaints on dealing with TCS and to be honest Im hesitant to send my TC to them for a freshening after my trans failure. Im really not sure what to do yet. I might drain it myself and try it but I know thats not the right thing to do. Then again if I get it back from them and its FUBAR Im screwed anyway. I only wanna R&R the trans once.

Lastly, Ive heard that there are some old style 9/11s that are still out there and available. You might try mike at race proven motors, hartman, or john waller to see if they have or know of any left.

HTH
 

jwaller

Evil Genius/SyTy Guru
I can still get the old 9-11's for ya if you like. and yeah I've bough a few dozen of them and as of lately some of them have been a bit looser than I would have liked but all in all I love the 9-11's. I have one in everything that I own. even my na 4.3 blazer. I won't use anything else.

to be honest there is nothing wrong with the old 9-11. the only reason I see using the new one is if your goin to be making 800hp and up.
 

canadian

sy in progress
i hear all this talk about loose and tight tc's. can someone give a primer as to what loose means and what tight means?
 

Tydriver

TurboLS6 Powa'
Why not consider a TC like the F-body boys are using. They turn higher RPMS than we do, but seems like the TC's are still holding up.

Same tranny(well ok, its called something else but similar guts), and they are throwing alot of HP and TQ at them

Just an Idea, if I didnt have a 9/11 TC in my closet waiting to be installed for over 2 years now I would go that route.
 

smeagol

Active member
Bottom of this page http://www.dragracingonline.com/technical/trannytech/v_1.html says it simplest. I'll cut & paste since it's short:

When someone says the converter is too tight, they mean it will not let the engine get up to the point where it starts making good power. When someone says the converter is too loose, the converter is letting the engine run up past peak torque and wasting power through slippage. Driving through the converter is also too loose or the converter will not load the engine to get all the power to the ground.

Like anything else, itís all in the combination.

Last line says it all :wink:

Also, a loose converter requires more throttle to move the truck than a tight converter would. Some converters are so loose that you will be able to take your foot off the brake while in gear, and the vehicle won't move. A loose converter can help spool up, but too loose will slip too much, costing power, and putting you out of your powerband (higher rpm than you'd like). A tight converter will hurt spool up, and will put you out of your powerband (on the low end). Kinda saying the same things as above.
 

Sy-1177

Turbo Inside
I have the old 9/11 and its about 6-8 months old and has roughly 500 or so miles on it. So far I love it and it woke up my 20g big time! Although I've never used a lockup switch on it, it seems to perform fine with no shudder that I can tell. My trans does shift a little easier now though as compared to before the TC when the shifts were firm. But that was also before my tranny rebuild so I can't say if it is the TC thats causing my softer shifts or not. In the end, for the $485 that I paid for it, I believe it was definately worth it! I haven't tried any others to compare it to but I couldn't see spending more than $500 on one either. I'd look into other options before I dropped that kind of cash on a product that gets such mixed reviews from users.

Had to edit my origianl post to reflect Brian's response to a loose converter. Mine does actually seem a little loose but hardly noticable. At idle, it will creep when I take my foot off the brake but its doesn't kill the power in the low end. I think its probably perfect for my aplication. (btw, its a 2800 stall)
 

smeagol

Active member
Loose or tight can be an opinion, but in some applications it will be cut & dry whether it's too much of a problem.

A stock motor truck stalling up to 3600-3800 on the line - too loose. That was my situation. When my built sy launched at a LOWER rpm than my stockish sy, using the same type of converter, that was fine. That one worked out great.

I have driven a stock turbo truck with a 9-11 that worked great. I was very impressed. The best launch in that truck was one with NO brake-torque. Hammer the gas from a stop, you had full boost within a truck length. Amazing. If every 9-11 worked like that, i'd recommend it for the stock trucks wanting one, as long as they didn't mind the looser feel around town.

With our trucks' limited RPM range, selecting a good torque converter is crucial. I've seen some people very happy with theirs, from a seat of the pants perspective, but I guarantee some of them may actually be SLOWING them down. Good datalogs, performance data is important sometimes.
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
I've been running a 9/11 in my truck for almost 4 years now and have never had a problem with it. It has outlasted 3 trannies and has never been rebuilt (IIRC). It is perfectly tuned for my build....not too tight/not too loose (just lucky I guess). I never really had a good basis for comparison with the old setup (stock motor, 20G, art carr 9" NLU converter, etc...), but it is much better than some other trucks I've ridden in (some with stock converters, some with 9/11s).

The only problem I have with it, is that it has always had a low speed shudder like BG described. Mine has gotten a little worse as of late (possibly due to wear/age of converter), but is still liveable. If you accelerate easily, at about 50 mph it will jump into lockup and 4th at the same time and the engine will bog a bit. Actually, at any rpm below 1900 it seems to drive uncomfortably. Enough that I leave it in D until I reach 55-60, then drop it into OD. The worst is 45 mph zones in town. Leaving it in D brings the rpms up and makes it uncomfortably loud, but dropping it into OD at that speed brings about low rpm shudder and any slight throttle blip and it's jumping out of LU and shifting into 3rd and back & forth. Due to all of this, I try to avoid the 45-55 mph zone like the plague.

Other than that, I like my particular converter a great deal. I have seen some 9/11s that are sloppy loose and some nutz tight, so I'm just grateful that mine has worked as well as it has.

Michael
 

smeagol

Active member
I've changed the lockup speeds in some programs to help this, but it really seems like a bandaid fix... typically raising lockup speed from 35 to 45mph, if I recall offhand. This helps it, but I really think it should be able to handle the lower lockup speed threshold.
 

CLONE

New member
I really don't like my old-style 9/11. It had the low speed shudder which I did the chip trick to mask. It's always been loose. I really don't think the TCS stuff is consistent enough. It also came from TCS filled with debris that had to be cleaned out.

The only good thing I can say about it is I haven't destroyed it yet.
 

JSM

Active member
I have one, and have had good luck.

Yes, it does have some "slip" when pulling out of driveway's, etc. But what can I expect for a 2800 stall. :D

I haven't had any shutter, atleast that I noticed or bothered me.

I noticed a similar thing that at 45mph, if you are in OD and TCC locks, engine bogs.

The TCC feels like a 5th gear in my application. ~40k miles on it, no issue yet.
 

Mad Mike

SYCOSIS
I have it in my syclone and while I do have the "shudder" when going into OD and the gas mileage sucks that's the only bad thing I can say. I believe it's the reason my truck runs 11's with just a small turbo (TE-45) and the Ultimate. Driveability is great for me, it's not loose at all, I get almost instant spool up on the street with just stabbing the throttle. Now , I don't drive it everyday but so far "knock on wood" it's been great!
 

Sy769

Donating Member
I wish I knew the cause of the shudder and the solution. My wife and I have are not as picky as some on driveability, but I dont want the shudder and I don't want such high stall speed that it kills performance.

My build:
Stock block,4bolt mains,eagles,SRP,Comp Cam,Vortecs,50# inj.,KB A2A, PTE 60

Ty 1450's build:stock motor,50# inj.,PTE60,

I feel that I could get away with a little more stall speed than he can considering I can easily shift mine at 5k without hurting it. However since they seem to be on the loose side lately I am tempted to go for a 2800 rating over a 3k. I don't want to kill spool but I don't want a stooopid loose converter either.

I have a lock-up converter that was rated for 2500 or so I guess I could get rebuilt if I could find someone to restall it higher.

Anyone have any other converters they like with a similiar build?

Jwaller What kind of deal can you get on a pair of converters??
 

ghettosled

SYTY SUPERSTORE
Well to make a long story short, I no longer can get the same 9/11s that we used to get. I bought what I was told was the last of the parts, and sold all 5 converters (at the discounted price). This was according to TCS. Maybe John can still get them, but I know I had to wait awhile for mine to show up.

Since that time I have contracted a local torque converter/transmission manufactor to start making converters for us. We have been using 10.5" lockup converters ranging from 2600-3200 stall and so far we have had great results. They are also much lighter then the 9/11s. I can have a custom spec'd converter done in 3-4 days.

Although we just started using them in the syty's very similar converters have been working in the F body crowd on many low 10sec street cars. I got the referral a local Fbody/corvette company who uses them exclusively on his supercharged 750hp corvette kits.

The price is $595. thanks
 

Brian Hartman

New member
Well, Patrick asked to post an answer to the question at hand so I threw this together. Hopefully it will help some of you. I also want to mention that a polls are misleading in forums like this sometimes. You know how it goes, if people are happy with something, you won't hear from them. The poll will be more revelant once a huge amount of 9/11 owners vote but at least you get to hear the bad experiences too which is good. I want to hear about the bad before I make a decision on buying something I've sold over 350 of these non billet 9/11 and they are running in most of the best trucks. I can honestly say there isn't a better TC out there eventhough some people might have had problems that were either blamed on the TC unjustly or correctly.

It’s true the old style billet thrust ring Third Gen 9/11 is not “readily” available. Yes, I can get them here and there but don’t sell them unless the person realizes it might take a while to get one. Usually the person is pissed by the time TCS can get it to them so I just don’t do it without getting my arm twisted.. Mike Lee bought 4 at the beginning of the year from me because he was willing to be the buffer for you guys. He would do the waiting for you so you wouldn’t have to. I sold 6 more of the old styles since then and am waiting on 1 still. The new billet ones are pretty quick in most cases. You do have to be careful though. There are several people out there that are copying the 9/11 and selling them as TCS 9/11’s when they aren’t. They buy some of the parts from TCS but not the important stuff because TCS doesn’t sell key parts to the 9/11. Rusty knows there are unscrupulous shops out there trying to copy his stuff and knows they can’t design their way out of a wet paper bag let alone a high performance 9/11 TC. Yes, they look similar but that is where it ends. Unfortunately this copy cat practice was the ultimate death of the old style 9/11. These 9/11’s were really nice and hauled ass. I never experienced a “loose” TC in any of my transmission builds. I know these transmissions like the back of my hand and only do them to the extreme but that is my business model. My transmissions are expensive but in order to cover my time, effort, and deliver what other shops don’t have the resources to deliver, the transmissions needs a lot of attention and the build method has to be strictly adhered to. I put WAY too much time and effort into these trannies and have figured it out. In retrospect, I wish I was doing something else with my life during all that time but heck, you live by your mistakes. Most shops, as you know, are lazy and will build trannies in 4-6 hours. Heck they even get lucky sometimes but most of the time, you get screwed in the end, especially if you have any problems. I don’t know how many times I’ve talked to a transmission shop on a friends behalf and passively listen to what these shops say not knowing I was on to them and what they were saying with in the first couple of words. Reminds me of listening to some of these hotshot wannabe computer gurus talking double talk while they are applying for a job in an interview. They are throwing around buzz words and twist talkin’ technology concepts that they want to make look like they know and you are just sitting there listening thinking this guy can’t be serious. Maybe that techno-babble works impressing mom but to think they think you are impressed with their total lack of knowledge is a little presumptuous. Plus I’m just itching to share this comic relief with my friends once I get a chance. Unfortunately, transtalk allows this same practice to be exercised without challenge most of the times. If you do challenge them, they tell you to get off their property and yell something about calling the cops or something. :eek: True Story! Anyway, There are lots of factors that contribute to the tightness of a TC. The factors are magnified as the TC gets smaller but the rewards are greater once you get the criteria for a smaller one met. You can go with a big sloppy 12” and even in transmissions with questionable builds, it will perform closer to the stall the TC was designed to stall at because the shear volume of fluid that is in there being beaten between the fins. But if you have a pressure OR a volume problem, in a lot of cases isn’t very noticeable in a low stall TC like a 12” or even a high stall 12”, you’ll see a big difference in a smaller TC like the “9”/11. This fact plays right into the hands of 99% of the transmission builders out there. They don’t trust their own builds to perform in a small TC condition. Their business model is to advertise performance and sell something less. They will sell a 12” because they don’t have to worry about come backs when their quality isn’t quite up to snuff. A 12” can mask their lack of effort to truly give what you as a customer wants. It’s similar to buying a car with a $99 Maaco special paint job because you are wanting a nice car. Sure, it looks ok from 1000ft away but it still isn’t a nice car but it simulates one in some ways and in some cases maybe that is all you want. Then they are successful and everyone is happy.

TC shudder is another thing I’ve answered in the past. I’m working on a fix that doesn’t require any prom editing. If you know what you are doing, you can fix it in the prom. What is causing the shudder is the fact that your foot isn’t pushing the throttle down very far and thus not signaling the tranny to increase pressure. Upping the MPH makes you push in a little more and thus eliminating the shudder. There are other parameters that will also correct this. Remember, most chips either think you have a stock tranny and TC or don’t account for the differences a high performance TC has in every different application. Custom chips are the way to go. Either learn it or have someone do it for you. I’ve seen several cool alternatives for DIYer chip tuners.

I have a cool new billet TC coming out soon that will take some mods to get to work. Nothing hard but you have to know what you are doing or know someone that does :wink: It isn’t aimed at the average SyTyer so I’ll just post it up on the my website once I get it going. No time right now. It’s more for the big power LT-1/LS-1 crowd but for SyTyers or GN guys that demand the best, this will definitely be it. Hopefully it will be ready and tested by mid summer. I have a bunch of new parts that I’ll be announcing soon too and again, these parts aren’t for the average build but cool none the less.

If you go back and search my posts back when I was more active on this board, you’ll see that I have answered almost all of the questions that still come up today like the one in this subject. If you have questions, feel free to email me at brianhartman@sprintmail.com I try to answer all my email but get overwhelmed a lot. I’m getting a lot of email from other boards.

I’ll be in Sacramento for 2 weeks. I will be there from the 1st of May up to around the 13-15th. I’m hooking up with some SyTyers out there and hope to meet up with other friends out there as well. If I drive, I’ll stop off in Reno to play with one of my best buddies, Yoda. This is Adam Auerbach’s crazy cat. :D I’ll have to time it when they aren’t sitting down to eat cow stomach or goat or whatever that was last time. Adam has a beautiful wife that cooks some weird food from the homeland. I’m not adventurious enough to call eating a bug dinner either. That is a horrible life altering motorcycle accident in my book. :D

I’ll be in Virginia later in the month so hopefully I’ll meet up with some of my East Coast pals.

I think I covered everything but might edit this later and add some stuff later tonight if I have time.

Have fun and don’t so out racing your shit if you are slower that you should be. :D That quote on JS’s tag is funny as hell. Why do people want to fight after getting their asses kicked in a race they started to begin with? Jeeez, happens more times than I want to count.
 

Syclone#892

Member
Well I when I bought my sy it had an old style 9/11 in it and a 20g turbo. I am assuming mine is very good or I just never noticed it being loose but to me it felt like I was driving a regular old vehicle, a fast one :D but nontheless it drove fine.
I can't wait to test it out on my new motor and see how it is.
I like mine though and I plan on getting the new billet one when I do my hartman tranny hopefully in the winter time, and I was planning on selling my old style but now that dad has a ty I guess it will probably go in that instead.
Good luck on your decision.
 
Top